图书标签: 政治学 社会运动 社会学 海外中国研究 威权主义 比较政治 政治社会学 politics
发表于2024-11-22
Mobilizing without the Masses pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024
When advocacy organizations are forbidden from rallying people to take to the streets, what do they do? When activists are detained for coordinating protests, are their hands ultimately tied? Based on political ethnography inside both legal and blacklisted labor organizations in China, this book reveals how state repression is deployed on the ground and to what effect on mobilization. It presents a novel dynamic of civil society contention - mobilizing without the masses - that lowers the risk of activism under duress. Instead of facilitating collective action, activists coach the aggrieved to challenge authorities one by one. In doing so, they lower the risks of organizing while empowering the weak. This dynamic represents a third pathway of contention that challenges conventional understandings of mobilization in an illiberal state. It takes readers inside the world of underground labor organizing and opens the black box of repression inside the world's most powerful authoritarian state.
Diana Fu is Assistant Professor of Asian Politics at the University of Toronto. This book builds upon her dissertation research at the University of Oxford where she studied as a Rhodes Scholar. Previously, she was a Walter H. Shorenstein Postdoctoral Fellow at Stanford University, California and a pre-doctoral fellow at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Her research has been supported by the Harold Hyam Wingate Foundation, the Chiang Ching Kuo Foundation, and the Rhodes Trust. Her academic articles have been published in Comparative Political Studies, Governance, and Modern China, among others. Her writing and research have appeared in The Economist, Foreign Affairs, The Washington Post, The Boston Review, PostGlobal, and Nicholas Kristof's 'On the Ground' Blog for The New York Times.
太稚嫩、格局太小了,除在中层加入介于组织与个体间的“无大众动员”外没有理论深度,大概看到倘若我本科直升读博做民族志的后果。上篇笼统地谈了劳工NGO,纵向中央和地方政府、横向不同政府机构对NGO的分散化管控,政府购买社会服务来促使竞争和收编管控。下篇对微观集体行动、个体化有幕后指导的行动、离散性行动三种策略的比较见P91,第一被直接镇压关停,第二采用个体威胁式行为达成诉求相对可行,第三用非暴力合作的文艺手段非常和谐。但是从零星的个体/组织行动到工人集体意识的启蒙到反权威政体意识的觉醒到对民主自由大众动员的乐观,这几步跳的太大了!一边是激进团体地下化去组织化的策略,一边是劳工在组织培训下参与个体抗争,两者完全没有融汇并切入政治+组织社会学理论核心,穿插的四个NGO案例毫无理论比较意义 M
评分书名针对下篇,讨论在劳工缺乏有效利益集体代表组织时如何通过法外手段实现诉求。作者讨论了微观集体行动、个体化行动、离散性行动三种策略,并将之视为认可国家权力下具有民主自由政治诉求的反权威统治行动。并预测“没有大众的动员”最终走向大众动员以及国家在“维稳”中成本和难度的几何级数上升。上篇讨论了这一套策略的宏观背景:地方有关民间组织和机构的碎片化管理以及对于“地上”组织的收编与合作,导致“地下”组织既有生存空间又饱受打压的状态。作者结论指出这一没有大众的动员是有律师为代表的激进团体与个人隐秘组织的结果。工人集体意识的觉醒使得政府控制难度增加。遗憾则是没有将工人集体意识的启发与革命时期意识形态宣传关联,未能看到革命/改革之间的断裂背反,也就未能将工人抗争对权威体制道德和意识形态正当性的消耗。
评分比较浅但Dedication page是亮点23333
评分正如标题讲的Mobilizing without Masses需要完成Mobilization和without masses两个任务。Diana可以在写作中对casing和framing的利用,来插入organizations在state-individual relationship的作用,全篇其实还是在讲dynamic interaction这个经典话题,只不过有state给予的条件,又有individuals的需求,所以有一个新的theoretical contribution,即处于collective action 和the weapon of weak中间的灰色地带。参看Diana的publications,她更熟练的是state and civil society而非微观组织。
评分书名针对下篇,讨论在劳工缺乏有效利益集体代表组织时如何通过法外手段实现诉求。作者讨论了微观集体行动、个体化行动、离散性行动三种策略,并将之视为认可国家权力下具有民主自由政治诉求的反权威统治行动。并预测“没有大众的动员”最终走向大众动员以及国家在“维稳”中成本和难度的几何级数上升。上篇讨论了这一套策略的宏观背景:地方有关民间组织和机构的碎片化管理以及对于“地上”组织的收编与合作,导致“地下”组织既有生存空间又饱受打压的状态。作者结论指出这一没有大众的动员是有律师为代表的激进团体与个人隐秘组织的结果。工人集体意识的觉醒使得政府控制难度增加。遗憾则是没有将工人集体意识的启发与革命时期意识形态宣传关联,未能看到革命/改革之间的断裂背反,也就未能将工人抗争对权威体制道德和意识形态正当性的消耗。
评分
评分
评分
评分
Mobilizing without the Masses pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024