We are beyond mere excitement about Lessons for the Young Economist. It is easily the best introduction to economics for the young reader—because it covers both pure economic theory and also how markets work (the domain of most introductory books).
Robert Murphy has the right frame of mind and mastery of the subject matter to provide the best possible pedagogy. The logic is super clear. The organization is impeccable. It achieves a great balance between “plain old” economics and that aspect of economic thought that is considered particularly Austrian. Therefore, it prepares the student for both conventional economic studies in the future and provides the logical rigor and policy clarity that only the Austrian School perspective can offer.
Most of the attempts at such texts falter because they are either too dry and technical for the young reader or they are littered with attempts to keep the student entertained with references to pop culture or cheesy passages that attempt to “speak the child’s language” but only end up sounding patronizing.
Dr. Murphy’s text has none of this. The prose has relentless fire without needless fireworks. What drives it forward is intellectual passion born of his love of the topic. What’s also nice is that he is nowhere self-consciously trying to sound like someone he is not. It is his real voice, explaining everything point by point. For this reason, the text is warm and engaging.
Here is the product of vast experience and daily writing. This permits the voicing of the book to achieve a remarkable integration page to page, chapter to chapter. Though he is drawing from the whole history of the development of economics, the text ends up being strikingly original. His approach is not based on anything but his own sense of how to teach this subject.
This book will not be boring or useless even for people who think they already know the subject. Every page or two, there are fresh insights. For example, on the problems with barter, he shows that in the real world, most goods and services would not have come into existence at all (so that there would be no trading of tractors for cobbler services because there would be no tractors or repairable shoes). In another place, he points out that one of the advantages of the division of labor is that it makes the advantages of automation more readily apparent.
Maybe these points appear in other introductory texts but the way he works them into a logical and seamless system is very impressive. It has a much larger market than just high-school students. Anyone can enjoy this book and learn from it. The appropriate age here is probably 13 and up but any adult will love this book.
Murphy wrote the first study guides to Human Action and Man, Economy, and State. He can now add another medal to his chest. It is a big one. There is every reason to believe that this book will still have powerful legs decades from now.
As for the price, it is close to being a miracle for a textbook of this size and expanse. The conventional publishers of bad books at high prices don't stand a chance against this landmark.
罗伯特·墨菲是美国著名经济学家、顾问、专栏作家和多部畅销书作者。他的热门文章经常出现在《洛杉矶时报》《华盛顿时报》《市场观察》《福布斯》和《投资者商业日报》等杂志上,作品包括《第一本经济学》《<人的行为>导读》《<人,经济与国家>导读》《选择》等。
尽管名义上是启蒙和科普,但对社会主义和计划经济的批判当真是一针见血,而对资本主义和市场经济面临的难题,却视而不见、顾左右而言他,不免透露出通过驳斥一堆低级荒谬的批判以显得万事大吉的心思。 真的万事大吉吗?如果假设成立便是。 如果没有垄断或许万事大吉。可哪没有...
评分墨菲说,他从法律上支持毒品合法化,虽然从道德上他支持禁毒。他的这个立场,和奥地利学派、马尔萨斯这些人的立场是一致的,或者说他和Sowell所谓的那些持有the tragic vision的人的立场是一致的。但是问题是,即使对人性、人的理性能力有悲观的态度,也没有必要放弃干预。当然...
评分 评分罗伯特·墨菲表达对计划经济的反感,跟表达对市场经济的着迷一样毫无遮掩,个人观点鲜明,不过也正因为个人观点鲜明,部分观念有些先入为主了。对市场经济的过于自信,导致在谈及政府对经济的干预时,火药味十足,有点将政府和经济对立起来的意思,这让我感觉很不快。我依然相...
按照章节顺序读下来会有很大的收获:经济学原来是这样的,有意思!比其他满眼模型公式的入门经济学读物更有逻辑,裂墙推荐!
评分比较之后
评分读到最后才发现是一本奥地利学派洗脑初中生的读物,但是最精彩的还是后半部分从论证社会主义开始到对政府干预的反对。
评分实际上,这本书和其它经济学初级课本之间的差距远没有我想象中的大。
评分对于初学者而言的极好入门书目,配合公开课的量化讲法学习,效果很好。只不过。。。被奥地利学派洗脑了,尤其是后半本,就是一直强调"政府不要干预政府不要干预政府不要干预",论证举例比较片面,不及前半本写的好,鲁滨逊的事例尤其赞。
本站所有内容均为互联网搜索引擎提供的公开搜索信息,本站不存储任何数据与内容,任何内容与数据均与本站无关,如有需要请联系相关搜索引擎包括但不限于百度,google,bing,sogou 等
© 2025 book.quotespace.org All Rights Reserved. 小美书屋 版权所有