图书标签: 社会学 社会阶层流动 经济学 社会学/人类学 经济史 历史 美国 社会科学
发表于2024-11-21
The Son Also Rises pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024
How much of our fate is tied to the status of our parents and grandparents? How much does this influence our children? More than we wish to believe. While it has been argued that rigid class structures have eroded in favor of greater social equality, The Son Also Rises proves that movement on the social ladder has changed little over eight centuries. Using a novel technique--tracking family names over generations to measure social mobility across countries and periods--renowned economic historian Gregory Clark reveals that mobility rates are lower than conventionally estimated, do not vary across societies, and are resistant to social policies. The good news is that these patterns are driven by strong inheritance of abilities and lineage does not beget unwarranted advantage. The bad news is that much of our fate is predictable from lineage. Clark argues that since a greater part of our place in the world is predetermined, we must avoid creating winner-take-all societies.
Clark examines and compares surnames in such diverse cases as modern Sweden, fourteenth-century England, and Qing Dynasty China. He demonstrates how fate is determined by ancestry and that almost all societies--as different as the modern United States, Communist China, and modern Japan--have similarly low social mobility rates. These figures are impervious to institutions, and it takes hundreds of years for descendants to shake off the advantages and disadvantages of their ancestors. For these reasons, Clark contends that societies should act to limit the disparities in rewards between those of high and low social rank.
Challenging popular assumptions about mobility and revealing the deeply entrenched force of inherited advantage, The Son Also Rises is sure to prompt intense debate for years to come.
Gregory Clark is professor of economics at the University of California, Davis. He is the author of A Farewell to Alms: A Brief Economic History of the World (Princeton).
一位研究平等的朋友力推。看完后觉得方法和结论都颇有新意,但另一面就是有争议吧。和目前关注的焦点不太一样,我还是关注短期政策层面的阶层流动
评分原来是一本正经的基因决定论!所以孩子还是不能收养啊
评分作者的核心论点是以氏族为单位的;所以当论点落至个人时,作者很谨慎的说了,一个人的成功(收入, y_{it})还是得看个人的奋斗。作者另外一个(争议性)论点政府干预无用论还需要解释另外一种可能性,即一般均衡效应。当一个政府于全国范围内实施某种政策,所有人都可能受益。因此在瑞典,当所有人都获得公立教育时,所有人都可能受益。相对来说,社会流动性可能不变;但以绝对标准衡量,所有人都有所提高(高收入)。于此论,作者的隐含辩驳是这种公立教育体系对于富家子弟影响甚小,所以衡量此政策应查看相对的收入或是相对的社会地位(作者证据)。作者结论是此政策无用。然而作者未有反驳一般均衡效应,而且作者于15章援引其它论文提到这种政策(if exogenously determined)是有可能有用的。
评分有些事情就是这么难以想象。
评分有些事情就是这么难以想象。
Clark这本书,我看了前面,把他的理论和方法论看完,就知道没有必要看下去了,因为剩下的案例,不管取自哪里,因为方法和理论的错误,就都没有意义了。 这本书的核心是什么?Clark说,传统测量社会流动的方法是:父母的外显性指标(比如收入、教育、资本等)和下一代的这些外显...
评分Clark这本书,我看了前面,把他的理论和方法论看完,就知道没有必要看下去了,因为剩下的案例,不管取自哪里,因为方法和理论的错误,就都没有意义了。 这本书的核心是什么?Clark说,传统测量社会流动的方法是:父母的外显性指标(比如收入、教育、资本等)和下一代的这些外显...
评分《儿子照常崛起》描绘的状况更加残酷,本书的观点简单说就是:家庭决定命运。通过考察超过20个社会中不同家族社会经济状况的历史变迁,克拉克得出结论:所谓社会流动几乎不存在。一个家族地位的提升或衰落不是3至4代人的事情,二一班需要10到15代。因此,克拉克估计,你出...
评分读此书的人一般会提到两点,第一是名字极度酷炫,第二是结论骇人听闻。对于看过Clark之前一本书的人来说,这应该很为眼熟,因为A Farewell to Alms也是借鉴海明威,而其“西方经济发展是因为富人生孩子多穷人都被饿死了”的结论也同样霸气。两者另外一个相似之处是内文同样枯燥...
评分读此书的人一般会提到两点,第一是名字极度酷炫,第二是结论骇人听闻。对于看过Clark之前一本书的人来说,这应该很为眼熟,因为A Farewell to Alms也是借鉴海明威,而其“西方经济发展是因为富人生孩子多穷人都被饿死了”的结论也同样霸气。两者另外一个相似之处是内文同样枯燥...
The Son Also Rises pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024