圖書標籤: 人類學 Gender Anthropology 民族誌 transgender LGBT ANTHROPOLOGY
发表于2025-01-07
Imagining Transgender pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2025
"Imagining Transgender" is an ethnographic examination of the emergence and institutionalization of "transgender" as a category of collective identity. Embraced by activists in the early 1990s as a means to advocate for rights and services specific to the needs of gender variant people, the category quickly gained momentum in public health, social service, scholarly, and legislative contexts. Working as a safe-sex activist in Manhattan during the late 1990s, David Valentine conducted ethnographic research, mostly among male-to-female transgender-identified people, across sites including drag balls, support groups, meetings of a cross-dresser organization, clinics, bars, and clubs. He found that while young fem queens were labeled "transgender" by social service agencies and activists, many of them either did not know the term or were fiercely resistant to its use. They self-identified as gay.Valentine analyzes the reasons for and potential consequences of this difference - between how some of the most vulnerable and marginalized gender variant people conceive of themselves and how they are perceived by service providers and others. Valentine argues that "transgender" was so rapidly adopted because it clarifies a model of gender and sexuality that has been gaining traction since the 1970s: a paradigm in which gender and sexuality are distinct arenas of human experience. Prevalent within feminism, psychiatry, and mainstream gay and lesbian politics, this distinction and categories based on it unintentionally exclude some gender variant people - particularly poor persons of color - for whom gender and sexuality are deeply connected experiences.Valentine does not oppose the rise of "transgender" as a category; he appreciates the genuine legal, medical, and social advances it has facilitated. Instead, he advocates a broad, inclusive vision of social justice and an attentiveness to the politics of language.
雖然Valentine是故意不去觸碰語言學這個大坑但我還是很好奇他怎麼看待這個問題。Queer來Queer去,當他批評白人男性、中産階級學術圈價值觀的同時,他是不是也在延續他們的語境?人作為社會動物可能無法脫離社會發展齣的語言架構和認知體係,但我們的是否能通過理論突破性彆的二元對立並使用全新的語言去探討這個問題?我們能否將gendered behavior看作純粹的個人選擇,如此承認生理性彆、生理性彆改變的可能性,將行為與生活方式看做為與性彆無關的個人選擇由此解構gender這一觀念本身?
評分本書通過民族誌方式,追溯transgender這一概念的形成以及應用。認為這一概念由gender/sexuality的分化而來。雖然這一概念為很多人提供瞭identity,但仍有大量變性者對這一身份不認同/不被認同。
評分文筆好啊。如此繁雜也寫得清楚。理論不是堅挺型的,但是對於理論的運用簡直是齣神入化。最有意思的一點是,這本書雖然是叫做人類學田野誌,但是骨子裏滲透著對人類學的不滿和批判啊。可以說Queer 瞭人類學,和人類學最基本的對於社區這個概念的認識,並且揭露瞭這樣一個認識背後的知識論的暴力。難得的人類學好書。而且對於trans的概念的結構,並不像Boellstorff 和 Kulick 之流 (田野中心論),作者並沒有把“詞匯、用語、語言“的解構放在核心位置,trans 是 becoming 而來,一直becoming 而去。作者很清楚的和Kulick之流劃清界限,告誡他們不要以一詞之定義來闡釋文化和權力互動。
評分雖然Valentine是故意不去觸碰語言學這個大坑但我還是很好奇他怎麼看待這個問題。Queer來Queer去,當他批評白人男性、中産階級學術圈價值觀的同時,他是不是也在延續他們的語境?人作為社會動物可能無法脫離社會發展齣的語言架構和認知體係,但我們的是否能通過理論突破性彆的二元對立並使用全新的語言去探討這個問題?我們能否將gendered behavior看作純粹的個人選擇,如此承認生理性彆、生理性彆改變的可能性,將行為與生活方式看做為與性彆無關的個人選擇由此解構gender這一觀念本身?
評分文筆好啊。如此繁雜也寫得清楚。理論不是堅挺型的,但是對於理論的運用簡直是齣神入化。最有意思的一點是,這本書雖然是叫做人類學田野誌,但是骨子裏滲透著對人類學的不滿和批判啊。可以說Queer 瞭人類學,和人類學最基本的對於社區這個概念的認識,並且揭露瞭這樣一個認識背後的知識論的暴力。難得的人類學好書。而且對於trans的概念的結構,並不像Boellstorff 和 Kulick 之流 (田野中心論),作者並沒有把“詞匯、用語、語言“的解構放在核心位置,trans 是 becoming 而來,一直becoming 而去。作者很清楚的和Kulick之流劃清界限,告誡他們不要以一詞之定義來闡釋文化和權力互動。
評分
評分
評分
評分
Imagining Transgender pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2025