图书标签: 英国  傲慢与偏见  P.D.詹姆斯  简·奥斯丁  推理  外国文学  P.D.James  小说   

喜欢 达西的疑问 的读者还喜欢

傲慢与偏见的侦探同人文，只看了开头和结尾的几章，还蛮不错的，很有时代感，人物的个性也比较合适。

第一本P.D.James，并没留下好印象。风格模仿原著大概只体现在节奏慢上面？Wickam的戏份搞那么悲情真是interesting。

能看得下去的续篇，对奥斯汀文风的模仿有几分相似，对比下却凸显原著作者的高明。作者小心翼翼地续写，开篇结尾僵硬地重复原著剧情实在没用。对人物的把握依然欠火候，没有奥斯汀掌控大局的轻松，以致全篇最丰满的形象是韦翰和改写个性的费茨威廉，一旦着笔少了人物就会ooc。案件线上没有推理情节，也没有处理好和彭伯里主客的关系，生硬地摆上仆人一家背锅，神奇地是案件居然没有和达西妹妹的婚恋线结合，这要是奥斯汀准在案件推进中让两位求爱者个性和预判来个逆转。最后，法庭戏最出色，心疼我上校。

完全不是PD詹姆斯原有的推理风格好么，翻译的也很文言文，看起来有点吃力。只能说是给简奥斯丁迷的一个傲慢与偏见的续集版本。

P·D·詹姆斯是我喜欢的英国侦探小说女作家，上次看了她的《灯塔》，颇有些念念不忘。这本《达西的疑问》借用奥斯汀名著中的故事与人物，加入侦探小说的情节，还原了十八世纪末十九世纪初英国的生活状况。关于那个年代的社交礼仪、司法与审判制度以及英法战争和美洲新大陆的开发等，都是确有其事的。我也相信作者会模仿奥斯汀的语气口吻，让我们熟悉的伊丽莎白、达西、宾利、韦翰等都不至于走了样。可惜这本书的翻译不太好，使得书中的人物仿佛是从《红楼梦》里走出来的，有很大的违和感，看起来不舒服。

Writing a sequel to so famous a classical literature work as Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice is not a task to be taken lightly with the writer’s reputation on the stake. Numerous attempts have been made but nothing great comes out of it. Therefore, it’...

Writing a sequel to so famous a classical literature work as Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice is not a task to be taken lightly with the writer’s reputation on the stake. Numerous attempts have been made but nothing great comes out of it. Therefore, it’...

Writing a sequel to so famous a classical literature work as Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice is not a task to be taken lightly with the writer’s reputation on the stake. Numerous attempts have been made but nothing great comes out of it. Therefore, it’...

Writing a sequel to so famous a classical literature work as Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice is not a task to be taken lightly with the writer’s reputation on the stake. Numerous attempts have been made but nothing great comes out of it. Therefore, it’...

Writing a sequel to so famous a classical literature work as Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice is not a task to be taken lightly with the writer’s reputation on the stake. Numerous attempts have been made but nothing great comes out of it. Therefore, it’...