圖書標籤: 哲學 英文版 思想史 literature Theory Philosophy French Derrida
发表于2024-11-26
Thinking the Impossible pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2024
The late 20th century saw a remarkable flourishing of philosophy in France. The work of French philosophers is wide ranging, historically informed, often reaching out beyond the boundaries of philosophy; they are public intellectuals, taken seriously as contributors to debates outside the academy. Gary Gutting tells the story of the development of a distinctively French philosophy in the last four decades of the 20th century. His aim is to arrive at an account of what it was to 'do philosophy' in France, what this sort of philosophizing was able to achieve, and how it differs from the analytic philosophy dominant in Anglophone countries. His initial focus is on the three most important philosophers who came to prominence in the 1960s: Michel Foucault, Gilles Deleuze, and Jacques Derrida. He sets out the educational and cultural context of their work, as a basis for a detailed treatment of how they formulated and began to carry out their philosophical projects in the 1960s and 1970s. He gives a fresh assessment of their responses to the key influences of Hegel and Heidegger, and the fraught relationship of the new generation to their father-figure Sartre. He concludes that Foucault, Derrida, and Deleuze can all be seen as developing their fundamental philosophical stances out of distinctive readings of Nietzsche. The second part of the book considers topics and philosophers that became prominent in the 1980s and 1990s, such as the revival of ethics in Levinas, Derrida, and Foucault, the return to phenomenology and its use to revive religious experience as a philosophical topic, and Alain Badiou's new ontology of the event. Finally Gutting brings to the fore the meta-philosophical theme of the book, that French philosophy since the 1960s has been primarily concerned with thinking the impossible.
Gutting選瞭一個幾乎不可能僅在一部著作中就能解釋清楚的題目,從中又非常有野心地決定討論法哲三巨頭,並且研究黑格爾,海德格爾和尼采對三人的影響,最終導緻沒有深入探討任何人物或觀念。僅從其對德勒茲的研究來看,幾乎完全不值得仔細閱讀,沒有涉及任何主要著作,也沒有參考任何德勒茲學者的研究。Gutting以同樣的方法研究德裏達和巴丟,卻提供不齣新的見解。總之是一部敗筆,同時也說明Gutting並不是一位嚴肅的哲學史傢。很失望。
評分目錄比正文豐富 係列。。。
評分兩百頁的正文,覆蓋的議題相當龐雜:法國教育體製對法國哲學的影響,黑格爾、海德格爾、尼采的遺産,薩特的尷尬地位,倫理轉嚮,宗教體驗的(不)可能性。Gutting長期以來溝通分析/歐陸的努力在這本書裏非常明顯,而在“風格的政治”已然被專題化的前提下,他對法國哲學著述方式的不滿恐怕會激化而非緩和現有的分歧。Gutting想象《差異與重復》的前言被匿名提交給一位分析形而上學傢評議,模仿其口吻寫瞭一篇拒稿報告,並建議這位作者先去讀一個Leiter Reports上推薦的碩士項目以便訓練哲學思維。
評分兩百頁的正文,覆蓋的議題相當龐雜:法國教育體製對法國哲學的影響,黑格爾、海德格爾、尼采的遺産,薩特的尷尬地位,倫理轉嚮,宗教體驗的(不)可能性。Gutting長期以來溝通分析/歐陸的努力在這本書裏非常明顯,而在“風格的政治”已然被專題化的前提下,他對法國哲學著述方式的不滿恐怕會激化而非緩和現有的分歧。Gutting想象《差異與重復》的前言被匿名提交給一位分析形而上學傢評議,模仿其口吻寫瞭一篇拒稿報告,並建議這位作者先去讀一個Leiter Reports上推薦的碩士項目以便訓練哲學思維。
評分兩百頁的正文,覆蓋的議題相當龐雜:法國教育體製對法國哲學的影響,黑格爾、海德格爾、尼采的遺産,薩特的尷尬地位,倫理轉嚮,宗教體驗的(不)可能性。Gutting長期以來溝通分析/歐陸的努力在這本書裏非常明顯,而在“風格的政治”已然被專題化的前提下,他對法國哲學著述方式的不滿恐怕會激化而非緩和現有的分歧。Gutting想象《差異與重復》的前言被匿名提交給一位分析形而上學傢評議,模仿其口吻寫瞭一篇拒稿報告,並建議這位作者先去讀一個Leiter Reports上推薦的碩士項目以便訓練哲學思維。
評分
評分
評分
評分
Thinking the Impossible pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2024