Editorial Reviews
Amazon.com Review
Guest Reviewer: Nathaniel Philbrick on 1493 by Charles C. Mann
Nathaniel Philbrick is the author of the New York Times bestsellers The Last Stand; In the Heart of the Sea, which won the National Book Award; Sea of Glory, winner of the Theodore and Franklin D. Roosevelt Naval History Prize; and Mayflower, which was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize in history and one of the New York Times' ten best books of the year. He has lived on Nantucket since 1986.
I’m a big fan of Charles Mann’s previous book 1491, in which he provides a sweeping and provocative examination of North and South America prior to the arrival of Christopher Columbus. It’s exhaustively researched but so wonderfully written that it’s anything but exhausting to read.
With his follow-up, 1493, Mann has taken it to a new, truly global level. Building on the groundbreaking work of Alfred Crosby (author of The Columbian Exchange and, I’m proud to say, a fellow Nantucketer), Mann has written nothing less than the story of our world: how a planet of what were once several autonomous continents is quickly becoming a single, “globalized” entity.
Mann not only talked to countless scientists and researchers; he visited the places he writes about, and as a consequence, the book has a marvelously wide-ranging yet personal feel as we follow Mann from one far-flung corner of the world to the next. And always, the prose is masterful. In telling the improbable story of how Spanish and Chinese cultures collided in the Philippines in the sixteenth century, he takes us to the island of Mindoro whose “southern coast consists of a number of small bays, one next to another like tooth marks in an apple.”
We learn how the spread of malaria, the potato, tobacco, guano, rubber plants, and sugar cane have disrupted and convulsed the planet and will continue to do so until we are finally living on one integrated or at least close-to-integrated Earth. Whether or not the human instigators of all this remarkable change will survive the process they helped to initiate more than five hundred years ago remains, Mann suggests in this monumental and revelatory book, an open question.
Timeline for 1493
200,000,000 B.C.: Geological forces begin to break up the world’s single giant continent, Pangaea, forever separating the hemispheres. After this, Eurasia and the Americas develop completely different suites of plants and animals.
1493 A.D.: Columbus sails on second voyage, establishing the first consequential European settlement in the Americas. Without intending to, he ends the long separation of the hemispheres—and sets off the ecological convulsion known as the Columbian Exchange.
1518: In the first environmental calamity of the modern era, accidentally imported African scale insects in Hispaniola lead to an explosion of fire ants. Spaniards flee the ant-infested island in droves; colonists in Santo Domingo hold procession in honor of St. Saturninus, praying for his aid against the insect plague.
1545: Spaniards discover the world’s biggest silver strike in Bolivia. In the next century, the world’s supply of this precious metal will more than double, giving Europe an economic edge that will help it colonize Africa, Asia and the Americas.
1549: Initial appearance of tobacco—the addictive American drug that becomes the first global commodity craze—in China. That same year, Hernán Cortés inaugurates the human part of the Columbian Exchange by signing the first contract to import large numbers of Africans to the American mainland.
1571: Miguel López de Legazpi colonizes Manila and establishes continual trade with China—Columbus’s life-long, never-fulfilled dream. Knitting the entire inhabited planet into a single web of trade, Legazpi’s actions are the beginning of today’s economic globalization.
~1615: Earthworms come to northern North America in English ship ballast. During the next three centuries, they will re-engineer forests from Ohio Valley to Hudson Bay.
1630-60: The gush of American silver finally causes its price to collapse, setting off a the world’s first global economic calamity.
1644: Collapse of Ming dynasty. Long struggle between remaining Ming in south and incoming Qing dynasty in north leads the latter to forcibly evacuate most of the southern coast; millions of dispossessed people pour into the mountains, where they grow maize and sweet potatoes, American crops first smuggled into China from Manila and other European bases.
1775: France’s Flour War, set off by high bread prices, persuades King Louis XVI to allow the pioneering nutritional chemist Antoine-Augustin Parmentier to stage a series of publicity stunts to persuade farmers to grow potatoes, a distrusted foreign species from Peru. Parmentier’s PR is so successful that broad swathes of northern Europe are soon covered with a monoculture of potatoes.
1781: Britain’s “southern strategy” pushes Gen. Cornwallis’s army into North America’s malaria zone, an area dominated by malaria parasites introduced from Europe and Africa. Defeated by malaria, the British army surrenders to a general it never fought: George Washington. This ends the Revolutionary War.
1845: Europe’s potato monoculture, which is unlike anything ever seen in Peru, turns out to be especially vulnerable to another Peruvian import, the potato blight. Ravaging the continent from Russia to Ireland, the blight causes a famine that kills an estimated two million people, half of them in Ireland.
~1867: Léopold Trouvelot, French amateur entomologist, smuggles gypsy moths to Medford, Mass., hoping to breed them with native silk-producing moths to produce a more robust silk-producer. Their almost immediate escape sets off an invasion that continues today. Trouvelot hurriedly returns to France before the dimensions of the problem can be known.
1880-1912: Industrializing nations, desperate for the elastic belts, pliable gaskets and the aborbent tires needed by steam engines and vehicles, buy every scrap of rubber they can get from the Amazon’s rubber trees, the sole source of high-quality latex. The ensuing rubber boom collapses after an Englishman smuggles rubber trees out of Brazil. Soon much of southeast Asia is covered with this foreign tree.
1979: The golden apple snail is sent from Brazil to Taiwan to launch an escargot industry there. It escapes, proliferates, and becomes a major menace to the island’s rice crop.
Review
“A muscular, densely documented follow-up [to Mann’s 1491] . . . Like its predecessor, 1493 runs to more than 400 pages, but it moves at a gallop . . . As a historian Mann should be admired not just for his broad scope and restless intelligence but for his biological senstivity. At every point of his tale he keeps foremost in his mind the effect of humans’ activities on the broader environment they inhabit.”
-Alfred W. Crosby, The Wall Street Journal
“In the wake of his groundbreaking book 1491 Charles Mann has once again produced a brilliant and riveting work that will forever change the way we see the world. Mann shows how the ecological collision of Europe and the Americas transformed virtually every aspect of human history. Beautifully written, and packed with startling research, 1493 is a monumental achievement."
-David Grann, author of The Lost City of Z
“Spirited . . . One thing is indisputable: Mann is definitely global in his outlook and tribal in his thinking . . . Mann’s taxonomy of the ecological, political, religious, economic, anthropological and mystical melds together in an intriguing whole cloth.”
-Jonathan E. Lazarus, The [Newark] Star-Ledger
“Fascinating . . . Convincing . . . A spellbinding account of how an unplanned collision of unfamiliar animals, vegetables, minerals and diseases produced unforeseen wealth, misery, social upheaval and the modern world.”
-Starred review, Kirkus
“A landmark book . . . Entrancingly provocative, 1493 bristles with illuminations, insights and surprises.”
-John McFarland, Shelf Awareness
“A fascinating survey . . . A lucid historical panorama that’s studded with entertaining studies of Chinese pirate fleets, courtly tobacco rituals, and the bloody feud between Jamestown colonists and the Indians who fed and fought them, to name a few. Brilliantly assembling colorful details into big-picture insights, Mann’s fresh challenge to Eurocentric histories puts interdependence at the origin of modernity.”
-Starred review, Publishers Weekly
“In 1491 Charles Mann brilliantly described the Americas on the eve of Columbus’s voyage. Now in 1493 he tells how the world was changed forever by the movement of foods, metals, plants, people and diseases between the ‘New World’ and both Europe and China. His book is readable and well-written, based on his usual broad research, travels and interviews. A fascinating and important topic, admirably told.”
-John Hemming, author of Tree of Rivers
“Fascinating . . . Engaging and well-written . . . Information and insight abound on every page. This dazzling display of erudition, theory and insight will help readers to view history in a fresh way.”
-Roger Bishop, BookPage
“Charles Mann expertly shows how the complex, interconnected ecological and economic consequences of the European discovery of the Americas shaped many unexpected aspects of the modern world. This is an example of the best kind of history book: one that changes the way you look at the world, even as it informs and entertains.”
-Tom Standage, author of A History of the World in Six Glasses
查尔斯·曼恩是《大西洋月刊》《科学》和《连线》杂志的撰稿人。他也为《财富》杂志、《纽约时报》《史密森尼》《名利场》《华盛顿邮报》供过稿,曾三次进入美国国家杂志奖决赛的作者,被美国律师协会、美国物理研究会、阿尔弗雷德·P·斯隆基金会和兰南基金会授予过与写作相关的奖项。他的著作《1491》赢得了美国国家学院传播奖的年度最佳图书奖。
越来越多的学者相信由哥伦布航海引发的生态变化是现代世界标志性事件之一。为什么欧洲会崛起并主宰世界?为什么曾经最富有的、社会结构最先进的中国会一落千丈?为什么奴役制度在美洲能大行其道?为什么是在英国发生工业革命?所有这些疑问都以关键的方式与哥伦布交换相关联。 ...
评分读的是知识也是耐心。一周 断断续续粗粗嚼了一遍。 这本书就是围绕着关键字展开,从旧大陆横跨大西洋至新大陆,越过太平洋到中国。 关键字:野生物种(蚯蚓、蜜蜂、树木、野草)、疾病(疟疾)、白银、(烟叶/红薯/玉米)、土豆、鸟粪肥、奴隶、种族大融合 有些关键字打开的细...
评分感悟集中在如下几点: 1、1493年,哥伦布拉开了全球化的序幕。即使不是哥伦布、不在1493,也终会发生。 2、全球化是人类文明不可逆的进程,但贸易自由化不容置疑的理念只是众多信仰中的一种。 3、中国史在明代中叶开始不得不增加与远方文明接触,源于1492年的地理大发现和1493...
评分这本书给我最大的启示是,我们对于世界的认知,往往受到我们所处时代和文化背景的局限。作者通过对历史的梳理和分析,揭示了许多被我们忽视的、却又至关重要的影响因素。我发现,自己在阅读过程中,常常会不自觉地将自己的现代观念套入到历史情境中,而作者则会及时地纠正我的这种偏差,让我用更开放和多元的视角去理解历史。作者的叙述充满了智慧,他不仅仅是在讲述过去,更是在引导我们思考现在和未来。我喜欢这种能够引发深刻思考的书籍,它们能够让我的精神世界得到升华。
评分这本书带给我的最大感受是,历史的进程从来都不是孤立的,每一个时代,每一个事件,都与其他事物有着千丝万缕的联系。作者巧妙地将不同地域、不同文化、不同领域的信息汇集在一起,展现出一种前所未有的宏观视角。我从来没有想过,看似毫不相关的元素,竟然能够如此紧密地联系在一起,共同塑造着人类文明的进程。阅读这本书,就像是打开了一扇扇通往未知世界的门,每一次翻页,都是一次全新的探索。我尤其喜欢作者在描述一些具体事物时的细致入微,那些器物、植物、动物的描写,都充满了生命力,让我仿佛能闻到空气中的味道,触摸到实物的质感。
评分这本书的封面设计就吸引了我,那种泛黄的纸张质感,配合上复古的字体,仿佛一下子就把我带到了那个遥远的年代。拿起它,首先感受到的就是它的分量,沉甸甸的,预示着内容定然是厚实且饱满的。我迫不及待地翻开了第一页,并不是急于寻找所谓的“故事线”,而是想先感受作者的笔触,文字的韵律。很快,我就被作者的叙事方式所吸引。他没有采用那种流水账式的记录,而是将那些看似分散的事件、人物、物品巧妙地编织在一起,形成了一幅宏大而精细的画卷。我能感受到作者在每一个细节上都下了巨大的功夫,无论是对某个历史事件的考据,还是对某个地理环境的描绘,都显得那么真实可信,仿佛我亲身经历了一般。
评分这本书带给我的不仅是知识的增长,更是视野的拓展。作者以一种全新的方式,将我带入了一个我从未设想过的历史图景。我之前对于许多地理区域和文化之间的联系,都有着模糊的认知,而这本书则将这些模糊之处一一串联起来,形成了一个清晰而完整的网络。我常常会因为作者的描述而产生想要去实地考察的冲动,去亲身感受那些历史的痕迹。作者的写作风格非常具有画面感,他能够用文字构建出栩栩如生的场景,让我仿佛置身其中。我尤其喜欢作者在描述一些重要的历史转折点时所展现出的那种洞察力,他能够准确地捕捉到那些关键的时刻。
评分我一直在寻找那种能够让我沉浸其中,忘记时间流逝的书籍,而这本书恰恰满足了我的需求。作者对于历史的解读角度非常独特,他不仅仅是罗列事实,更是在挖掘事件背后的逻辑和联系。我常常会在阅读的过程中,突然因为作者的一句话而恍然大悟,之前那些模糊不清的画面瞬间变得清晰起来。这种“顿悟”的感觉,是阅读的最大乐趣之一。而且,作者在写作时,仿佛拥有多个视角,他能够从宏观的角度审视整个历史的走向,同时又能深入到微观的层面,展现普通人的生活状态。这种全景式的展现,让历史不再是枯燥的数字和年代,而是鲜活的生命群像。
评分我一直认为,一本好书,不仅仅是知识的载体,更是情感的共鸣。这本书在这方面做得非常出色。作者在讲述历史事件时,并没有将人物塑造成高大全的形象,而是展现了他们的喜怒哀乐、爱恨情仇,让他们变得真实而有血有肉。我常常会在阅读到某个感人的故事时,热泪盈眶;也会在读到某个令人振奋的篇章时,心潮澎湃。作者的文字非常有感染力,他能够轻易地触动人心最柔软的地方。我特别喜欢书中那些关于人性的探讨,那些关于选择、关于牺牲、关于坚持的故事,都让我受益匪浅。
评分我一直对那些能够颠覆我固有认知,让我重新审视世界观的书籍情有独钟。这本书正是这样一本。作者以一种极为严谨的态度,从各种角度剖析了历史的复杂性和多面性。我原本以为自己对某些历史事件已经有了足够的了解,但这本书的出现,让我意识到自己过去的认识是多么的片面。作者的论证过程非常清晰,逻辑严密,即使是对于一些复杂晦涩的概念,他也能用通俗易懂的语言加以解释。我尤其欣赏作者在处理历史细节时那种不放过任何一丝可能的态度,这种严谨性是许多其他书籍所缺乏的。
评分我承认,一开始我对这本书的标题有些困惑,它并没有直接点明书中的内容,反而留下了一种神秘的悬念。然而,正是这种神秘感,驱使我想要去探究其中的奥秘。随着阅读的深入,我逐渐理解了作者的良苦用心。他并非想要用一个简单的标题来概括一切,而是希望读者能够通过自己的阅读,去发现和理解那些隐藏在字里<bos>中的深刻含义。作者的语言风格非常多变,有时是冷静客观的叙事,有时又是充满激情和哲思的评论,这种变化让阅读过程充满了惊喜。我常常会在读到某个精彩的段落时,忍不住停下来,反复品味其中的文字,感受作者的匠心独运。
评分我曾经读过许多关于历史的书籍,但没有一本能够像这本书一样,让我如此深刻地感受到历史的脉络和力量。作者的叙述方式非常独特,他并没有遵循传统的历史叙事模式,而是将各个看似独立的事件有机地联系在一起,展现出一种全局性的视角。我常常会在阅读过程中,因为作者的某个比喻或类比而茅开朗。他善于将抽象的概念具体化,让复杂的历史事件变得易于理解。我尤其欣赏作者对于因果关系的分析,他能够清晰地展示出每一个事件是如何影响着后来的发展,这种深邃的洞察力,是我在其他书籍中很少见到的。
评分我一直认为,阅读的最高境界,是能够与作者进行一场跨越时空的对话。这本书无疑达到了这样的境界。作者的观点虽然有其独到之处,但并不显得极端或偏激,而是充满了理性和思辨。我常常会在思考作者的论点时,不断地反驳自己,然后又在作者的进一步阐述中找到新的思路。这种思维的碰撞,是阅读过程中最令人兴奋的部分。作者的语言风格非常简洁有力,他善于用最精炼的语言表达最深刻的含义。我喜欢这种不冗余,直击核心的写作方式。
评分充满良心的作品 引经据典 实地考察 也不缺乏思考 对美洲历史、生物学和全球化感兴趣的可以看看
评分这书太娘们了,没有干货。
评分connected Columbus' explorations to the collapse of Ming dynasty. very intriguing. I like his way to light up the connections between events
评分connected Columbus' explorations to the collapse of Ming dynasty. very intriguing. I like his way to light up the connections between events
评分connected Columbus' explorations to the collapse of Ming dynasty. very intriguing. I like his way to light up the connections between events
本站所有内容均为互联网搜索引擎提供的公开搜索信息,本站不存储任何数据与内容,任何内容与数据均与本站无关,如有需要请联系相关搜索引擎包括但不限于百度,google,bing,sogou 等
© 2026 book.quotespace.org All Rights Reserved. 小美书屋 版权所有