图书标签: 国际关系 唐世平 方法论 比较政治 制度经济学 制度变迁 国际政治 国关理论
发表于2024-12-23
A General Theory of Institutional Change pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024
Institutional change is a central driving force behind social changes, and thus a central topic in all major fields of social sciences. Yet, no general theory of institutional change exists. Drawing from a diverse literature, this book develops a general theory of institutional change, based on a social evolutionary synthesis of the conflict approach and the harmony approach. The book argues that because the whole process of institutional change can be understood as a process of selecting a few ideas and turning them into institutions, competition of ideas and struggle for power to make rules are often at the heart of institutional change. The general theory not only integrates more specific theories and insights on institutional change that have been scattered in different fields into a coherent general theory but also provides fundamental new insights and points to new directions for future research. This book makes a fundamental contribution to all major fields of social sciences: sociology (sociological theory), political sciences, institutional economics, and political theory. It should be of general interest to scholars and students in all major fields of social science.
Shiping Tang is Professor at the School of International Relations and Public Affairs (SIRPA), Fudan Univeristy, Shanghai, China. He has a very broad research interest and has published widely. He is the author of A Theory of Security Strategy for Our Time: Defensive Realism (Palgrave-Macmillan 2010), A General Theory of Institutional Change (Routledge, 2011), and Social Evolution of International Politics (Oxford, 2013, forthcoming). He is also the co-editor of Living with China: Regional States and China through Crises and Turning Points (Palgrave-Macmillan 2009). His most recent journal publications include articles in Chinese Journal of International Politics, European Journal of International Relations, International Security, International Studies Review, Journal of Economic Issues, Journal of Strategic Studies, Review of International Studies, Philosophy of the Social Sciences, Security Studies, and World Politics.
一星扣给期望值
评分还有几章没看完。作者将以往解释机制变迁的理论分为“和谐”、“冲突”两大路径,有些粗略,文献回顾提到的基本都是最高级大牛。然后夸大、绝对化两条路径各自的缺点(以往一些理论为了将理论做得深刻,且坚持自己范式的优秀性而故意使用较少的变量,同时不愿意借用对方阵营的理论来调和自己的范式,进而的确存在一些解释力不足的现象)。再提出自己的所谓大一统理论,声称可以弥补以往理论的不足,将两大路劲置于自己设计的理论框架之下。进而借用生物学进化的因果机制解释、对应机制变迁。类比有些简单,且难免有王婆卖瓜之嫌。目前尚未看到扎实的案例验证。唐老师可能是比较擅长理论演绎
评分唐老师的这本书,还是比较易懂的。其中部分内容可见《社会科学的基础范式》。
评分Logically coherent as promised, but kind of over-gerenal. 高度强调制度内部的权力关系的重要性有一定的启发性。唐大师还是很善于推销自己的理论的,但或许在一些地方有些曲解他所加以批判的那些靶子。例如批评哈贝马斯的公共领域和交往行为理论抽掉了权力的因素,不切实际,但人家哈贝马斯的关怀就不在于唐老师所讲的制度变迁…
评分炫技作品。长处是把权力和观念的变迁和interplay纳入制度变迁的框架。最大的弱点可能是变迁的阶段论无始无终,每阶段都是共时发生,如果要构成实证上摸得着的阶段只能对制度粗暴地分离与简化。对“冲突”路径的批评也有些奇怪,批评该路径无法解释如果制度是偏向胜者的利益为何人类总体welfare如何增进了,但同时他采用对welfare的测量是人口,人均寿命和人均GDP? 另,这本书里“naive”的出现频数是读过的文献综述里最多的:)
读完此书第一感受是,作者对于自己构建的制度变迁的广义理论十分自信,全书随处可见对所谓和谐学派与冲突学派的批判,用词毫不客气,“伎俩”、“欺骗”、“诡计”、“幻想”之类词语随处可见。通读全书,读者则会发现作者具有明显的西方学者的写作风格,这自然与其国外的求学...
评分读完此书第一感受是,作者对于自己构建的制度变迁的广义理论十分自信,全书随处可见对所谓和谐学派与冲突学派的批判,用词毫不客气,“伎俩”、“欺骗”、“诡计”、“幻想”之类词语随处可见。通读全书,读者则会发现作者具有明显的西方学者的写作风格,这自然与其国外的求学...
评分读完此书第一感受是,作者对于自己构建的制度变迁的广义理论十分自信,全书随处可见对所谓和谐学派与冲突学派的批判,用词毫不客气,“伎俩”、“欺骗”、“诡计”、“幻想”之类词语随处可见。通读全书,读者则会发现作者具有明显的西方学者的写作风格,这自然与其国外的求学...
评分读完此书第一感受是,作者对于自己构建的制度变迁的广义理论十分自信,全书随处可见对所谓和谐学派与冲突学派的批判,用词毫不客气,“伎俩”、“欺骗”、“诡计”、“幻想”之类词语随处可见。通读全书,读者则会发现作者具有明显的西方学者的写作风格,这自然与其国外的求学...
评分读完此书第一感受是,作者对于自己构建的制度变迁的广义理论十分自信,全书随处可见对所谓和谐学派与冲突学派的批判,用词毫不客气,“伎俩”、“欺骗”、“诡计”、“幻想”之类词语随处可见。通读全书,读者则会发现作者具有明显的西方学者的写作风格,这自然与其国外的求学...
A General Theory of Institutional Change pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024