圖書標籤: 藝術評論 精神分析 johnOnians Neuroarthistory 2018
发表于2024-11-25
Neuroarthistory pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2024
This provocative book offers a fascinating account of one of the newest and most exciting fields in the human sciences: neuroarthistory. In recent decades there has been a dramatic increase in both the quantity and the quality of our knowledge about the brain, especially the visual brain. The number of art historians making use of the new neuroscience is growing and the insights they gain by doing so are compelling. Knowledge of phenomena such as neural plasticity and neural mirroring is making it possible to answer with a new level of precision some of the most challenging questions about both the creative process and the response to art. This is equally true whether their framing is positivist or postmodernist. John Onians devotes each of his twenty-five chapters to a specific writer, or 'neural subject', each of whom recognised that the mind was a part of human nature. As the neural basis of the mind became more and more apparent, they became clearer about how an understanding of that neural basis could contribute to an understanding of all human behaviours, including art. The level of agreement among major thinkers such as Montesquieu, Burke, Kant, Marx and Freud, and leading art historians such as Pliny, Winckelmann, Ruskin, Pater, Taine, Wolfflin, Riegl, Gombrich and Baxandall, not to mention artists such as Alberti and Leonardo and scientists such as Aristotle at the beginning and Zeki at the end of the twenty-five centuries covered in the book, is startling. So, too, is the extent to which their penetrating observations match the findings of modern neuroscience. Anyone wondering whether to making use of neuroscience themselves should read this book. It will change most readers' view not only of the history of art history, but of the history of art itself - and even of the history of culture.
本以為是通過各個時期對於腦結構,視神經的認識來重新闡釋亞裏士多德以來對於藝術史的書寫,結果隻是用現代研究成果去套古人的“前瞻性。”而其中所謂的科學基本不齣mirror neurons和"neural plasticity"兩點。更讓人匪夷所思的是每章的結尾Onians還用環境決定論來解釋每個哲人的論點(比如貢布裡希思想中的自覺性源於他二戰時在倫敦等公交車過程中耳聞目染的各種視覺衝擊)。如果想瞭解神經生物學給藝術史帶來的啟示,Margaret Livingstone的Vision and Art (第二版, 2013年)要有意思的多。
評分本以為是通過各個時期對於腦結構,視神經的認識來重新闡釋亞裏士多德以來對於藝術史的書寫,結果隻是用現代研究成果去套古人的“前瞻性。”而其中所謂的科學基本不齣mirror neurons和"neural plasticity"兩點。更讓人匪夷所思的是每章的結尾Onians還用環境決定論來解釋每個哲人的論點(比如貢布裡希思想中的自覺性源於他二戰時在倫敦等公交車過程中耳聞目染的各種視覺衝擊)。如果想瞭解神經生物學給藝術史帶來的啟示,Margaret Livingstone的Vision and Art (第二版, 2013年)要有意思的多。
評分本以為是通過各個時期對於腦結構,視神經的認識來重新闡釋亞裏士多德以來對於藝術史的書寫,結果隻是用現代研究成果去套古人的“前瞻性。”而其中所謂的科學基本不齣mirror neurons和"neural plasticity"兩點。更讓人匪夷所思的是每章的結尾Onians還用環境決定論來解釋每個哲人的論點(比如貢布裡希思想中的自覺性源於他二戰時在倫敦等公交車過程中耳聞目染的各種視覺衝擊)。如果想瞭解神經生物學給藝術史帶來的啟示,Margaret Livingstone的Vision and Art (第二版, 2013年)要有意思的多。
評分re-write history of art
評分從亞裏士多德到孟德斯鳩都是平鋪直敘,到溫剋爾曼和康德有個小高峰,接著是維捨爾到沃爾夫林的二次高峰,最後從貢布裏希開始就進入瞭激戰,盡管作者作為貢布裏希學生的身份,多少粉飾瞭這場爭論的“血腥程度”
評分
評分
評分
評分
Neuroarthistory pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2024