图书标签: 历史 社会学 历史社会学 历史哲学 Sewell 史学理论 人类学 history
发表于2024-11-24
Logics of History pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024
While social scientists and historians have been exchanging ideas for a long time, they have never developed a proper dialogue about social theory. William H. Sewell Jr. observes that on questions of theory the communication has been mostly one way: from social science to history. Logics of History argues that both history and the social sciences have something crucial to offer each other. While historians do not think of themselves as theorists, they know something social scientists do not: how to think about the temporalities of social life. On the other hand, while social scientists’ treatments of temporality are usually clumsy, their theoretical sophistication and penchant for structural accounts of social life could offer much to historians.
Renowned for his work at the crossroads of history, sociology, political science, and anthropology, Sewell argues that only by combining a more sophisticated understanding of historical time with a concern for larger theoretical questions can a satisfying social theory emerge. In Logics of History, he reveals the shape such an engagement could take, some of the topics it could illuminate, and how it might affect both sides of the disciplinary divide.
William H. Sewell Jr. is the Frank P. Hixon Distinguished Service Professor of Political Science and History at the University of Chicago. He is the author of three previous books, including Work and Revolution in France and A Rhetoric of Bourgeois Revolution.
不同学科的人对这本书的评价很不一样,跟与这本书有关的学术史有关,也跟各学科方法和材料-立论-分析之间的度有关。如何理解和评价是个有些意思的话题。|休爷您就不能不那么罗嗦么?完全可以化约节省至少四分之一的篇幅也讲得清诶
评分历史社会学:结构的崩溃与转型。结构与能动性相互构成,结构的缝隙带来市民社会能动性的可能,集体的能动性则带来结构的变革。
评分六到九章只是粗讀了一下。一個歷史學家寫出(據說是)美國社會學引用第28高的論文(本書第四章),歎為觀止。
评分Sewell的总结能力太好了,像个编字典的人(虽然好奇为什么全书没引一个Latour) . 喜欢他对Charles Tilly和Marshall Sahlins的解读,尤其是后者,Islands of History如当头一棒
评分Eventful sociology. Contingent event The world is under no obligation to confirm to the logic by which some people conceive of it.- Marshall Sahlins. Event, structure,cultural transformation and social change.Social construction.--Hermeneutical quantification--(Description--Explanation--Interpretation.) Not language, semiotic,Not articulation.
我接触休厄尔这本书的时间不算早,之前在课上和其他作品中大致知道了一些这本书中的观点。后来写毕业论文时又找来翻过了一遍,以求能寻找一些灵感。中译本出来时很是兴奋,但读过第一章后,觉得这本书的翻译暂时没有符合我原有的期待。 不过先要肯定两位译者非常用心。凡是做过...
评分我一开始对社会学产生极大的兴趣——想来可能同很多其他社会学学生一样——是上本科理论课读韦伯齐美尔一摩尔经典理论家让我脑洞大开,觉得他们既能极好的勾勒出从传统社会到现代社会的变迁,又能极犀利地铺陈出对现代社会的反思和批判。这种求知的兴趣往往到了当代理论就遇到...
评分 评分除了吐槽之外,我还是再写点正经的吧。 ff老师说这本书对于她的启发在于,要去寻找历史事件发生背后的结构。刚才看到笔记人老师说,这本书对于他的意义主要在于,历史学家能从人类学家那里学到什么。但对我来说,这本书的价值在于给那些通过不同的途径生产出来的知识找一个各...
评分Sewell这本书的主要目的是想把结构和行动带到一块去,把“文化”和“社会”带到一块去,以及最终是要把社会科学家和有人文学科倾向的历史学家带到一块去。他对“文化”和“结构”的理解,以及他对于事件史方法的应用,其实遵循的都是同一个思路。 不过上面那些我之前基本都已...
Logics of History pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024