圖書標籤: 五四 學生群體 曆史學 Lanza 海外中國研究 政治化 馬剋思主義及其研究 革命
发表于2024-11-25
Behind the Gate pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2024
On May 4, 1919, thousands of students protested the Versailles treaty in Beijing. Seventy years later, another generation demonstrated in Tiananmen Square. Climbing the Monument of the People's Heroes, these protestors stood against a relief of their predecessors, merging with their own mythology while consciously deploying their activism. Through an investigation of twentieth-century Chinese student protest, Fabio Lanza considers the marriage of the cultural and the political, the intellectual and the quotidian, that occurred during the May Fourth movement, along with its rearticulation in subsequent protest. He ultimately explores the political category of the "student" and its making in the twentieth century.
Lanza returns to the May Fourth period (1917-1923) and the rise of student activism in and around Beijing University. He revisits reform in pedagogical and learning routines, changes in daily campus life, the fluid relationship between the city and its residents, and the actions of allegedly cultural student organizations. Through a careful analysis of everyday life and urban space, Lanza radically reconceptualizes the emergence of political subjectivities (categories such as "worker," "activist," and "student") and how they anchor and inform political action. He accounts for the elements that drew students to Tiananmen and the formation of the student as an enduring political category. His research underscores how, during a time of crisis, the lived realities of university and student became unsettled in Beijing, and how political militancy in China arose only when the boundaries of identification were challenged.
I like the approach
評分隻討論瞭五四前後的北大學生,這讓epilogue裏轉到討論六十年代/八十年代比較缺少更復雜的context,畢竟五四後政黨活動對學生政治影響非常大。藉用列斐伏爾、朗西埃等理論,本書視學生的政治化為一個試圖超越國傢界定、規訓的政治、生活空間之外尋求自主的社會空間生産過程。考察瞭學生的日常生活、北大的1917年改革、學生校內的學會活動、學生抗議的空間符號政治等等方麵。總的來說有以論代史的感覺,作者的解讀發揮甚於展現曆史行動者的想法,且利用迴憶錄等材料的過程中較少討論這些材料本身的局限。
評分I like the approach
評分西馬理論套五四北大校史,日常生活史部分最有啓發,但很多arguments真有些汪暉的味道,以論代史的感覺還是太強,對史料的檢討卻太弱。藍是個好學者,但這本書真的讓人不滿意
評分隻討論瞭五四前後的北大學生,這讓epilogue裏轉到討論六十年代/八十年代比較缺少更復雜的context,畢竟五四後政黨活動對學生政治影響非常大。藉用列斐伏爾、朗西埃等理論,本書視學生的政治化為一個試圖超越國傢界定、規訓的政治、生活空間之外尋求自主的社會空間生産過程。考察瞭學生的日常生活、北大的1917年改革、學生校內的學會活動、學生抗議的空間符號政治等等方麵。總的來說有以論代史的感覺,作者的解讀發揮甚於展現曆史行動者的想法,且利用迴憶錄等材料的過程中較少討論這些材料本身的局限。
評分
評分
評分
評分
Behind the Gate pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2024