图书标签: 历史  海外中国研究  白莲教  清史  清朝  海交与航海  history  社会史   

喜欢 White Lotus Rebels and South China Pirates 的读者还喜欢

• 
  The Making of the Chinese State pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  Provincial Patriots pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  Early Modern China and Northeast Asia pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  Qing Colonial Enterprise pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  Critical Han Studies pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  The Crisis of Global Modernity pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  Ancestral Leaves pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  Culinary Nostalgia pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  Emperor Qianlong pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  Building Culture in Early Qing Yangzhou pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载

An ambitious project that attempts to challenge the narrative of the early-19-century Qing by re-interpreting Daoguang Reign as a "restoration" that prepared China for the problems to come in the next century. Both complimented and criticized by scholars, somehow too ambitious. But also a good thought that calls for new researches into this perio

不是很喜欢这个写法和路数。头三章减分。

还没读书先读了罗威廉的书评，罗的批评非常尖锐，另外顺道把哈佛出版社批判了一番。/读完了，确实差。。。不知所云，不觉得嘉庆改革和两个叛乱之间关系多大，也不觉得什么全方位危机这个概念有任何用处。。彭慕兰和王国斌你们两位放这论文过关良心不会痛嘛。。

文笔害死题目。主题不错，角度时段亦可回应晚近著作过分强调大清为何/何时药丸、丸后意义之弊。然表意之劣，逻辑之混乱，题目关系之无序，借用社科理论和历史研究碎片之随意，实令鄙人怒发冲冠，颇想夺过书稿重写一遍。全本硬销所谓全方位危机不知新意何在，事件结构节点之关系是社科经典命题，但开头提一下即无所影踪。写叛乱突然引入环境史、叛乱生态、施坚雅层级模型、斯科特无政府人类学视角、曼恩社会权力论，见啥偷啥。内廷改革与皇帝官僚关系部分本身不错，但和叛乱关系不清，如何表明事件结构节点之关系？写海盗与对外关系一章云里雾里，跟内廷改革关系又何在？白莲教那边既无此类影响为何特意加插一章造成不均衡？到结尾方才抛出帝国建构学与治理术变化、国家退行与社会脱轨、自主发展和叛乱，跟药丸趋势如何耦合等问题，然为时已晚。

构思约有三点：填补嘉道研究的薄弱处（回应中国史学界叙事），追溯波拉切克inner opium war的源头（回应美国清史叙事），加入borderland/frontier相关讨论（回应帝国转向和新清史），还要照顾社会史方法，头绪太多，结果搞成一堆浆糊。第六章讨论政治制度转型中的内廷行政制度化、军机处权责转移，以及结论对可持续发展政治模式的总结还可一读，以华中和东南两类非内亚frontier相排比的想法也有些启发，其余基本无足观。文风很混乱，估计原本就是清史叙事习惯，为了满足编辑要求而加进去一些社科概念和学术史。对外关系一章尤其不知所云。

Wensheng Wang, White Lotus Rebels and South China Pirates: Crisis and Reform in The Qing Empire. Harvard University Press, 2014 ---Jiaqing period: Crisis, Wei (danger) + Ji (opportunity) ---continuity: between splendid 18th century and crisis-laden mid-19t...

Wensheng Wang, White Lotus Rebels and South China Pirates: Crisis and Reform in The Qing Empire. Harvard University Press, 2014 ---Jiaqing period: Crisis, Wei (danger) + Ji (opportunity) ---continuity: between splendid 18th century and crisis-laden mid-19t...

Wensheng Wang, White Lotus Rebels and South China Pirates: Crisis and Reform in The Qing Empire. Harvard University Press, 2014 ---Jiaqing period: Crisis, Wei (danger) + Ji (opportunity) ---continuity: between splendid 18th century and crisis-laden mid-19t...

Wensheng Wang, White Lotus Rebels and South China Pirates: Crisis and Reform in The Qing Empire. Harvard University Press, 2014 ---Jiaqing period: Crisis, Wei (danger) + Ji (opportunity) ---continuity: between splendid 18th century and crisis-laden mid-19t...

Wensheng Wang, White Lotus Rebels and South China Pirates: Crisis and Reform in The Qing Empire. Harvard University Press, 2014 ---Jiaqing period: Crisis, Wei (danger) + Ji (opportunity) ---continuity: between splendid 18th century and crisis-laden mid-19t...