图书标签: 政治学 政治 民主 民主理论 刘瑜推荐 RobertADahl 美国民主 政治哲学
发表于2024-11-25
Polyarchy pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024
“In this book, Professor Dahl carries forward his logico-empirical studies of the conditions under which political systems change or are transformed from one type to another. . . . The focus here is upon the conditions under which systems he designates as closed hegemonies, inclusive hegemonies, or competitive oligarchies are likely to develop into polyarchies, or intermediate variations thereof… To this reviewer, the present book enhances Professor Dahl’s status as political diagnostician and analyst. It exemplifies beautifully the function of theory in disentangling the elements of a problem and understanding the relations between them, as distinct from constructing general, logically consistent theories that do not explain variations and deviant cases in the real world, or devising ‘practical’ solutions without knowing whether or why they work. Dahl uses concepts to reveal and enlighten us as to hidden relationships in the data.” —Avery Leiserson, The Annals
"Dahl extends his inquiry inot pluralistic social orders to the conditions favorable for a competitive political regime, or polyarchy. . . . This is good Dahl, it is both political theory and comparative government, and the appendices add valuable data . . . . It belongs in every library collection, and it might have use as a supplementary text."—Choice
"A tightly woven explanation of the conditions under which cultures that do not tolerate political opposition may be transformed into societies that do. The author is at his empirical best in reaching his conclusions."—Foreign Affairs
"His purpose is primarily analytical rather than presciptive, and his analysis is lucid, perceptive, and thorough."—Times Literary Supplement
Robert A. Dahl, Sterling Professor Emeritus of Political Science and Sr. Research Scientist Sociology, is a member of the National Academy of Sciences, the American Philosophical Society and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, a corresponding member of the British Academy, and a past President of the American Political Science Association. His publications include Congress and Foreign Policy; Politics, Economics and Welfare (with C. E. Lindblom); A Preface to Democratic Theory; Who Governs? Democracy and Power in an American City; After the Revolution?; Polyarchy; Size and Democracy (with E. R. Tufte); Dilemmas of Pluralist Democracy; A Preface to Economic Democracy; Controlling Nuclear Weapons: Democracy Versus Guardianship; Democracy and Its Critics; Toward Democracy: A Journey; On Democracy; How Democratic is the American Constitution?, Politica e virtu' , La teoria democratica de nuovo secolo, After the Goldrush: Growing up in Skagway and On Political Equality.
这才是科学
评分3星。被老师要求读,非常痛苦。除了第一章提出的民主和polyarchy的定义有点意思外,后面的分析从现在的角度看是非常不值得读的。作者的分析就像是想列举所有会影响polyarchy的因素一样,但明显这是一个无法穷尽的工程。也没有迹象表明作者列举的因素是最重要的,或者是符合因果关系的。从这本书的所得确实非常有限。
评分AP的人早都忘了Dahl的时候,CP的老师们把Dahl带了过来。那一个年代的研究做法固然不同,但是范式本身就是最有意义的部分。
评分此书的日译本是高畠通敏所译,在日本政治学界有着非常广泛的引用。几乎影响了一代日本政治学者怎样思考他们国家的民主政治,进而形成了80年代之后颇有影响的日本政治的"多元主义”的民主模型。自然,从现在的角度来看,这个模型在日本的运用大体是失败的。如同市场经济在美国和日本被分别称为liberal和coordinated市场经济的模式一样,民主政治的宏观运行在这两个国家也同样如此。相较于学者们通过公司在市场交易中的作用来界定这两个国家不同的市场经济一样。学者们也一度曾经希望通过政治和社会精英的关系来理解不同民主的运行。这种切入问题的思路,在暂且不考虑政治制度(总统制对议会内阁制)的具体差异的条件下,其理论的框架事实上也是非常模糊的。所能够搜集的证据,事实上既不能支持这个理论,也并不支持它的对立理论
评分文字干净又不乏深意,非常喜欢这种不标榜不夸张的研究态度。至于现实意义,现代民主体制的判断方法与其评估普遍基于Dahl的两个dimensions。至于新意,这本书出版于on democracy之前,甚至第三次民主浪潮还未开始
评分
评分
评分
评分
Polyarchy pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024